DOE PAGES title logo U.S. Department of Energy
Office of Scientific and Technical Information
  1. SiC Substrate Composition Effect on TGO Scale Growth in EBC Systems During High‐Temperature Steam Exposure

    A systematic investigation was conducted on the oxidation behavior of silicon-bond coats within environmental barrier coating (EBC) systems applied to Si-carbide (SiC) substrates, aiming to understand how different underlying SiC substrates influence the bond coat's thermally grown oxide (TGO) and its properties. The study examined (Y/Yb)2Si2O7/Si coatings on three cost-effective surrogate SiC substrates (chemical vapor deposition [CVD]-grown β-SiC, sintered α-SiC, and reaction-bonded [RB] SiC) for SiCfiber/SiCmatrix ceramic matrix composites (CMCs). Discrepancies in TGO growth were observed, with noticeably higher growth rates reported for the coated CMC specimens than for the four monolithic SiC specimens. The CMC samples produce an amorphousmore » TGO, whereas the other monolithic substrates formed a crystalline TGO, which lowered the oxygen permeability through the SiO2 scale. In conclusion, the vitrification of the TGO in the (Y/Yb)2Si2O7/Si/CMC system resulted from the migration of boron species from the CMC substrate to the SiO2 scale, leading to network modification via boron doping.« less
  2. Characterization of SiO2 Thermally Grown Oxide Stress Evolution of EBCs with Al-Containing Dopants

    SiC/SiC ceramic matrix composites (CMCs) are desired for use in combustion environments to achieve higher turbine operating temperatures. However, CMCs require environmental barrier coatings (EBCs) for protection from the gas environment. EBC systems are known to primarily fail through coating delamination via growth of a thermally grown oxide (TGO) at the EBC—silicon bond coating interface when exposed to steam, which accelerates the TGO growth rate. The TGO undergoes a phase transformation during thermal cycling, which results in stresses that may encourage EBC spallation. Yb-silicate EBCs with mullite and yttrium aluminum garnet (YAG) dopant additions were deposited on SiC substrates withmore » a Si intermediate bond coating and exposed to thermal cycling in steam at 1350 °C. The impact of Al dopant additions on the TGO growth rate and the SiO2 phase transformation was assessed. Photo-stimulated luminescence spectroscopy (PSLS) was used to characterize the Al-containing phases and to measure stress evolution in the EBC following exposure using the stress-induced peak shift of the R-lines of mullite. Raman microscopy was used to map the stresses in the Si bond coating following exposure. It was found that the TGO phase transformation upon cooling increased compressive stress in the Si bond coating within 15 µm of the TGO.« less
  3. A model to assess Zircaloy’s mechanical property changes following a transient beyond critical heat flux

    Maintaining the integrity of nuclear fuel rods is essential for ensuring public health and safety in nuclear power generation. During reactor operation, this integrity is confirmed by demonstrating compliance with established regulatory acceptance criteria. For moderate-frequency events, such as limiting transients and anticipated operational occurrences (AOOs), the current fuel integrity criterion is based on preventing boiling transition. This criterion assumes that prevention of boiling transition will prevent excessive cladding heating and, thus, fuel failure during normal operations. While conservative, this approach places significant constraints on core design, fuel cycle economics, and a plant’s ability to perform major power uprates, leadingmore » to suboptimal fuel utilization and inefficient carbon-free energy production. A more efficient approach could be achieved by revising the failure criterion to a material-specific limit rather than strictly preventing the boiling transition, since boiling transition per se is not a cause of fuel cladding failure. Here, as a result, a new licensing framework based on material properties, termed time-at-temperature (t@T), is needed. This approach would allow for brief periods of post–critical heat flux operation during an AOO without compromising safety. Implementing the t@T licensing strategy requires a robust technical foundation in material properties, which must be established through comprehensive data collection on both unirradiated and irradiated fuel and cladding materials. This foundation would enable the development of a safety basis that ensures safe operation while providing greater flexibility and efficiency for reactor operation. This paper documents a thorough review of the available data to establish a baseline knowledge that can inform the development of cladding mechanical models, as well as identify experimental data gaps that need to be addressed in future research. Machine learning and data informatics were utilized to extract the importance of parameters on the t@T parameter. Industry tools were used to perform baseline analyses to define the relevant transient conditions for data analysis. The subsequent review successfully identified applicable experimental data, as well as sufficient data to evaluate changes in cladding mechanical properties following an AOO transient. Rather than developing new models, this work coupled existing irradiation annealing and recrystallization models to calculate changes in hardness, yield stress, and ultimate tensile stress following an AOO event. The findings from this review were summarized to highlight the experimental data needs required to fill remaining gaps and support the development of future t@T licensing methodologies.« less
  4. A statistical representation of bond coating oxidation under environmental barrier coatings

    Environmental barrier coatings (EBCs) protect SiC-based ceramic matrix composites (CMCs) in turbine hot sections from high-temperature volatilization in combustion gases. The formation of a SiO2 thermally grown oxide (TGO) is expected under the EBC after long-term operation. The oxidation resistance of the EBC is understood as a life-limiting factor for the CMC, and this work predicts long-term oxidation behavior under EBCs through a simple statistical approach. Specimens were exposed to 1350°C isothermal conditions for 100-h thermal cycles in flowing steam for up to 1000 h. The EBC morphology, SiO2 thickness, and SiO2 cracking behavior were assessed. Using thousands of SiO2more » thickness measurements across many millimeters of the interface, a realistic representation of the entire TGO was captured via a lognormal distribution. The lognormal fit parameters were extrapolated out to 25 000 h to assess the degree of SiO2 growth, the spread of SiO2 thicknesses related to the rough oxidizing interface, and percentages of the intermediate bond coating consumed. In conclusion, local interfacial defects from the coating deposition process are identified as local failure points for EBC—CMC systems.« less
  5. Recrystallization driven softening and heating rate dependencies of FeCrAl nuclear fuel cladding during accident transients

    A refined understanding of FeCrAl cladding behavior during rapid transients is critical for its potential deployment in light-water reactors. Current assessments focus on transient burst testing metrics such as balloon geometry, burst temperature, and hoop stress, often used as proxies for simpler conventional tensile properties. However, directly correlating isothermal tensile and creep data with accident transient scenarios remains a challenge, although it is essential for high fidelity model development. Recent modeling based on tensile tests up to 800 °C, conducted with both immediate loading and a 10-minute soak, showed that immediate loading better predicts experimental burst temperatures, indicating a thermalmore » softening effect. Building upon this observation, the current study connects transient performance, microstructural evolution, and high-temperature tensile properties by leveraging results from C26M claddings burst tests performed at heating rates of 1–50 °C/s and hoop stresses from 25 to 100 MPa. At 25 MPa, rupture temperatures varied by only 6 °C, but at 100 MPa, the difference reached 116 °C, with faster heating yielding higher burst temperatures. Microstructural analysis identified recrystallization as the primary cause of heating rate-dependent softening, eliminating prior cold-working. In-situ thermomechanical data linked ballooning onset to localized instabilities, similar to ultimate tensile strength behavior in conventional tensile tests. High heating rates correlated with immediate loading tensile data, while lower rates matched soaked data. Furthermore, by linking burst performance to microstructural evolution and tensile properties, this work provides a foundation for more accurate modeling of FeCrAl claddings and potentially other Fe-based materials under accident conditions.« less
  6. In-situ strain behavior and BISON simulations of Zircaloy cladding subjected to temperature cycling separate-effects tests in a steam environment

    Understanding fuel system performance during anticipated transients without scram (ATWSs) in boiling water reactors (BWRs) is necessary for refining current and future safety limits. High-fidelity material models and simulations are fundamental to rigorous assessment of zirconium-based cladding performance. However, experimental thermomechanical data during simulated ATWSs to validate these modes are limited. To provide relevant in-situ data, Zircaloy-4 cladding was subjected to cyclic heating in a steam environment to simulate an out-of-pile BWR ATWS. Digital image correlation was used to capture the cladding strain behavior in-situ for comparison against simulations using the BISON finite element code. Conventional high-temperature models were comparedmore » using multiple schemes to gain a better understanding of the applicability of three BISON models to BWR ATWS: (1) the default combination of creep models in BISON, (2) the high-temperature Erbacher model alone, and (3) the low-temperature Limback-Andersson model alone. The cases run with the Limback-Andersson model alone produced the lowest root mean square error (RMSE). The lowest RMSE for the Limback-Andersson model alone was 0.659%, and the highest RMSE reported was 4.22%. A data gap within the model in the temperature regime of interest was also identified, and to account for this gap, the current model in BISON is linearly interpolated between two separate datasets. In conclusion, this evaluation highlights the need to either develop a new model or to improve the existing model to capture transient creep effects resulting from a cyclic temperature transient.« less
  7. Melting temperature, emissivity, and thermal conductivity of rare-earth silicates for thermal and environmental barrier coatings

    In recent years, rare-earth silicates have become the industry standard for coating state-of-the-art SiC ceramic matrix composite (CMC) gas turbine engine components, due to their low volatility, high melting point, and thermal shock resistance. Current research is focused on designing rare-earth silicate based thermal-environmental barrier coatings (T/EBCs) with improved resistance to CMAS (CaO-MgO-Al2O3-SiO2), steam, and crack formation, while maintaining high temperature performance and stability. Here, in this work we compare the high temperature performance of a variety of single and multi-component rare-earth mono- and disilicates (MS, DS) and rare earth apatites by measuring their melting points and spectrally averaged visiblemore » emissivities using laser heating and radiation pyrometry. We also report room temperature thermal conductivity measured by time-domain thermoreflectance (TDTR).« less
  8. Interface stability of ultrasonic additively manufactured Zircaloy-4 during hydrothermal corrosion

    Simulated pressurized water reactor conditions (330 °C, 15.6 MPa, ~20 ppb oxygen) without irradiation were used to investigate the hydrothermal corrosion behavior of ultrasonic additively manufactured Zircaloy-4 up to 1000 h. X-ray computed tomography allowed for visualization of defects from processing and their progression after corrosion experiments. The specimens were found to have clear variability in the mass change data, compared to typical wrought Zircaloy-4 specimens. The variation in the mass change after exposure was attributed to weld defects connected to the specimen surface which allowed ingress of oxidant into the samples. Defects visualized by computed tomography were found viamore » metallography and characterized. In conclusion, ultrasonic additively manufactured Zircaloy-4 was found to have comparable corrosion behavior as wrought Zircaloy-4 for specimens which did not have clear surface defects along weld interfaces.« less
  9. Environmental barrier coatings on SiC without a silicon bond coating: oxidation resistance, failure modes, and future improvements

    Environmental barrier coatings (EBCs) are used to mitigate chemical reactions between SiC ceramic matrix composite (CMC) components and the H2O in combustion gas in turbine hot sections. CMCs are currently temperature-limited by the Si-bond coating, which melts at ~ 1414 °C. This work explores EBCs where the bond coating was removed to achieve higher operating temperatures. Various versions of enhanced roughness SiC were utilized to improve EBC adhesion to the substrates prior to 1 h furnace cycle testing in steam at 1250–1425 °C. The enhanced SiC roughness resulted in short coating lifetimes as the roughness was oxidized away with SiO2more » formation. Further, isothermal furnace exposures at 1400–1600 °C showed Yb2Si2O7/Yb2SiO5 EBC microstructural changes, resulting in premature debonding from the substrates. Finally, this work provides baseline requirements for the development of both next-generation EBCs and bond coating strategies to overcome the current limitation of the Si-bond coating melting temperature.« less
  10. Holistic comparison of environmental barrier coating material candidates through design of a figure of merit

    The first figure of merit for environmental barrier coating (EBC) materials was designed through a ranking system for material properties pertaining to established EBC failure modes in service. Seven past, present, and novel EBC candidate materials were used in the figure of merit design: SiO2, Ba0.75Sr0.25Al2Si2O8 (BSAS), HfSiO4, Yb2Si2O7, Yb2SiO5, Yb2O3, and YbPO4. Utilizing compiled data from the literature, the presented figure of merit verified Yb2Si2O7 as the state-of-the-art candidate with optimal EBC properties and inferred that YbPO4 should be considered as a potentially viable EBC material candidate. Further, the figure of merit allows for a holistic comparison of EBCmore » candidates and informs experimental and computational search efforts for next-generation complex EBCs. Clear knowledge gaps found through this work include CaO–MgO–Al2O3–SiO2 (CMAS)-resistant coatings, EBC lifetimes before delamination, and oxidant diffusion rates in relevant EBC microstructures. It was shown that while some materials show promise for solving a single key failure mode for EBCs (i.e., CMAS reactivity), a community-wide goal should be placed on materials development to achieve acceptable resistance against all major failure modes, which are interconnected. Novel compositionally complex EBC materials, in addition to layered EBC architectures, show promise for the optimization of material properties for long-lifetime EBCs in combustion environments.« less
...

Search for:
All Records
Creator / Author
"Ridley, Mackenzie "

Refine by:
Article Type
Availability
Journal
Creator / Author
Publication Date
Research Organization